Why Buy an Existing Restaurant vs an Asset Sale:​​

​

Opportunity for Growth

An existing restaurant often has significant unrealized potential that can be unlocked through effective leadership and strategic initiatives. With sound management, new proprietors can identify and capitalize on growth opportunities that previous owners did not pursue or were undercapitalized to achieve fully. ​

 

Potential for High Return on Investment

While businesses facing financial challenges may initially appear risky, those with solid foundations and favorable market positions can bring considerable profitability upon revitalization and reorganization. The process of transforming a struggling establishment into a thriving enterprise presents substantial prospects for high returns to individuals willing to undertake such initiatives.​

​

Lower Purchase Price

Typically, "transition" businesses are available at lower purchase prices than their successful counterparts. This affordability enables buyers to acquire promising establishments, particularly when only restructuring or operational enhancements are required for success.​

​

Expedited Market Entry

Fully equipped transition restaurants facilitate swift conversion to new concepts. In many cases, modifications such as updated signage, menu improvements, and décor will suffice, allowing new owners to bring their vision to market efficiently.

 

​​Risk Assessment

Despite its appeal, purchasing a transition restaurant involves considerable risk alongside potential reward. A thorough evaluation is imperative before pursuing such opportunities. Achieving success necessitates diligence, commitment, and a readiness to address complex challenges; for those who prevail, the experience can prove highly gratifying.​

​

Asset Sales

​

​What is the value of an asset sale?

Asset sale values are contingent upon location, but under typical market conditions, buyers generally pay between 20–30% of the original build-out cost. For instance, if the initial investment was $300,000, the asset sale price may be approximately $90,000.​

 

Why aren’t books and records available?

Asset sales are not priced as a “going concern” because new owners will implement their own menus, staff, brands, and promotional strategies. Remaining elements are limited to infrastructure and décor; thus, historical financial records are largely irrelevant.​

 

Cost to Open

Asset sales and turnaround opportunities are competitively priced, offering turnkey solutions that typically require minimal additional investment. These arrangements generally include necessary equipment and fixtures, reducing upfront expenses.

 

Operational Readiness

Timeliness is crucial in the restaurant sector. Delays may result in lost market opportunities. Acquiring an asset sale circumvents common startup barriers, enabling prompt implementation of operational changes.

 

Lease Assignment

The location and terms of a restaurant’s lease are instrumental to its success. Increasingly competitive markets have intensified the challenge of securing favorable leases, making asset sales an advantageous acquisition method. Lease assignments often offer more favorable terms than negotiating new leases, because in many cases, current lease costs have increased more than the annual increases (escalations) since the time the original lease was negotiated.

​

Restaurant asset sales are commonly priced using the Replacement Value Method, wherein buyers compensate the seller based on the current investment in the facility, including leasehold improvements, equipment, location, and existing leases. This approach reflects the value of avoiding the substantial time, expense, and effort required to build a new restaurant and comply with regulatory requirements, permitting delays or construction timelines.  In rare instances, sellers may command a premium due to desirable locations; however, more frequently, failed concepts lead to spaces being designated as "second generation" and sold as asset sales. In these cases, sellers often receive only a fraction of their original investment.​

 

Asset sales are valued using the replacement cost methodology solely when assets are offered without demonstrated earnings. Listings should clearly indicate that it is an asset sale, with no financial records available. Buyers are essentially acquiring furniture, fixtures, equipment, and location, rather than ongoing operations or established profitability.​

​

 

While on a Buyer Site Visit

​

​Professional Behavior 

Conducting an anonymous visit is one of the most informative steps prospective buyers can take. This allows an unbiased assessment of the establishment’s operations and environment.  Remember, many sellers are seeking complete confidentiality in the sale of their business and are concerned they may lose guest loyalty and staff morale if news of the sale leaks.  It is imperative not to discuss the sale with any staff or management, and not to take photos openly, as this will signal that you are there as a potential buyer.  You will have ample opportunity to discuss the sale with the brokers or in a buyer-seller meeting.

 

​​Key areas for evaluation during such visits include:

​

Overall Location: Evaluate the establishment’s setting and accessibility.

Parking: Assess customer parking availability and convenience.

Signage: Review visibility and effectiveness of external signage.

Staff Interaction: Observe staff professionalism and guest service quality.

Cleanliness: Inspect the dining area, restrooms, and kitchen for cleanliness.

Menu: Consider menu diversity, presentation, and relevance to the restaurant concept.

​